Skip to content
Reciprocity Accounting card: Low Volume Looks Like Rising Overhead, a Problems post.
Problems

Low Volume Shows Up as Rising Overhead Percentage, Not Falling Revenue

Greg Hudnall
Greg Hudnall

Problems  ·  6 min read

When overhead climbs and nothing got more expensive, the problem is the bottom of the fraction. A slower schedule raises every cost percentage at once, and cutting costs is the wrong first move.

A practice that loses patient volume rarely sees it first as lower revenue. It sees overhead go from 61% to 66% of net production, staffing tip over 30%, and an owner who starts looking for something to cut. Most of a dental practice's costs are fixed for the month, so when production shrinks, the same costs get divided by a smaller number and every ratio rises together. So when a cost percentage looks alarming, look at the actual dollars before you react to the ratio. Percentages and dollars do not always tell the same story. If total expenses held still and the percentage rose, nothing got more expensive. You did less dentistry.

This is not a hypothetical worry this year. In the ADA Health Policy Institute's Q3 2026 survey, 38% of dentists said they were not busy enough and could have treated more patients, up from 26% in Q2 (ADA HPI, State of the U.S. Dental Economy, Q3 2026). The same report found that from January through August, prices for dental equipment and supplies rose 0.2% and hourly earnings of dental office staff rose less than 0.1%. Nationally, the two cost measures HPI tracks held still and the schedules got lighter.

The Ratio Moved but Nothing Got More Expensive

Overhead is a fraction. Expenses sit on top, net production sits underneath. A healthy practice runs it at 55% to 65% of net production, as our post on total overhead percentage explains, and that post makes the point this one is built on: when you are over 65%, start with production, not with expenses.

Owners usually start the other way, for an understandable reason. The P&L lists expenses line by line, with amounts and names you recognize. Production shows up as one number at the top. When the bottom line disappoints, the eye goes to the long list. But a fraction can rise because the top grew or because the bottom shrank, and the two need opposite responses.

Fixed Cost Over a Shrinking Denominator

Take the illustrative one-doctor, one-hygienist practice from our post on what an empty chair costs per hour. In a full month it does $90,000 of net production. Its variable costs (lab, supplies and card fees, which rise and fall with the dentistry) are $12,300. Its fixed costs (payroll, facility, equipment, software, insurance and marketing) are $42,500.

Now run two different bad months.

LineFull monthVolume falls 10%Spending rises
Net production$90,000$81,000$90,000
Variable costs$12,300$11,070$12,300
Fixed costs$42,500$42,500$47,200
Total expenses$54,800$53,570$59,500
Overhead % of net production61%66%66%
Staff payroll % ($25,000, unchanged in the volume month)28%31%28%
Profit before owner pay$35,200$27,430$30,500

Both bad months land at 66% overhead. One practice spent $4,700 more. The other spent $1,230 less, because a lighter schedule uses less lab and fewer supplies, and still posted the same ratio. Its staffing percentage also crossed out of the 25% to 30% band without a single raise or hire, which is exactly the pattern our staffing percentage post warns about.

The volume month is also the more expensive of the two. Profit fell $7,770, against $4,700 in the spending month. A 10% drop in this practice is about 13 of its 128 practice hours, and at the roughly $607 of margin each of those hours carried for both chairs together, that is the full $7,770.

Our free Dental Practice Benchmark Scorecard checks your overhead, staffing and clinical cost against the healthy ranges in about two minutes. If more than one of them moved out of range in the same month, read the rest of this post before you act on any of them.

How to Tell the Two Apart in One Look

Put this month's total expenses next to the same figure for the trailing 12-month average. Then do the same for net production.

Total expensesNet productionWhat it usually means
Flat or ↓ Down↓ DownVolume or fee problem. The ratio rose because the denominator shrank.
↑ UpFlatSpending problem. Find the lines that grew.
↑ Up↑ Up, fasterGrowth. The ratio may fall even as you spend more.
↑ Up↓ DownBoth at once. Fix the production side first, because, as in the example above, it is often the bigger lever.

There is a second check inside the P&L itself. Variable costs should hold a steady share of production in both directions, because they move with the work. If lab and supplies stayed near the same percentage while everything else rose, that is the signature of a smaller denominator. If lab or supplies jumped as a percentage on their own, you may have a pricing or coding issue, and our posts on supply and lab cost cover those.

One caution before you trust the production number. If your books run on cash, the denominator is deposits, and a slow month for insurance payments can make overhead look high with no change in the schedule at all. Our post on how cash basis hides overhead problems shows that swing in detail. Read overhead against net production, not against what landed in the bank.

Why Cutting Costs Here Makes It Worse

Suppose the owner of the volume month decides to get back to 61% by cutting. At $81,000 of production, 61% overhead means total expenses of about $49,400. Variable costs are already $11,070, so fixed costs would have to fall to about $38,300, a cut of roughly $4,200 a month.

Look at where $4,200 a month would have to come from. Payroll is $25,000 of this practice's $42,500 in fixed cost. The rest is facility at $7,000, a lease you cannot renegotiate this month, equipment at $3,000, software, insurance and fees at $5,500, and marketing at $2,000. Short of wiping out most of a whole category, the only account big enough is payroll, and payroll is the capacity that produces the dentistry. Cut hygiene hours and you remove production faster than you remove cost, the same trap our hygiene productivity ratio post describes. Cut an assistant and the doctor slows down. The ratio can go up again after the cut.

Compare the other path. Filling those 13 hours back recovers the full $7,770 and returns overhead to 61% with no cuts at all. A fix on the production side is worth almost twice what the cut would save, and it does not shrink the practice to get there.

That does not mean spending never matters. It means the order matters. A practice that cuts first and asks about volume later has usually made the volume problem harder to fix.

The Order to Check Things In

Work it top to bottom. Each step either answers the question or sends you to the next one.

1. Net production against your own trailing 12 months. Compare the same month last year as well, since many practices have seasonal months. If production is down, the overhead increase is probably mostly arithmetic.

2. Total expenses against the same 12 months. A flat total with a higher ratio confirms a denominator problem. A rising total sends you to step 5.

3. Visits versus value per visit. Production falls either because fewer patients came in or because each visit is worth less. Booked hours and patient visits from your practice software answer the first. Gross production against net production answers the second: if write-offs grew, a fee schedule or payer change is shrinking the denominator, which our payer mix post covers.

4. Where the empty time is. Doctor hours and hygiene hours carry different margins, and the hygiene schedule feeds the doctor's. If hygiene production slipped as a share of the total, start there.

5. Only then, the spending lines, largest first. Payroll, then clinical cost, then facility, then everything else. A two point move in payroll is worth more than eliminating a small subscription, as the overhead post says.

Marketing deserves its own note, because it is the line owners cut first when production falls. A flat marketing budget against a falling schedule is a volume problem, not a spending one, and our post on marketing as a spend problem or a volume problem works through that test.

P.S. Reciprocity Accounting closes dental practice books by the 10th of every month, so you can see whether last month's overhead moved on the top of the fraction or the bottom while you can still act on it. See how we can help your practice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my dental overhead percentage rising when my expenses have not changed?

Because overhead is a fraction, and the bottom of it shrank. Most practice costs are fixed for the month, so lower net production divides the same costs by a smaller number. Compare total expenses to your trailing 12 months before you look at the percentage.

How do I know if I have a volume problem or a spending problem?

Look at total expenses and net production side by side against your own trailing average. Flat expenses with lower production is a volume or fee problem. Higher expenses with flat production is a spending problem.

Should I cut staff when overhead goes over 65%?

Not first. If the cause is lower volume, payroll is the capacity you need to recover it, and cutting it usually removes production faster than cost. Check production, visits and write-offs before any spending line.

Can a fee schedule change raise my overhead percentage?

Yes. If more of your production goes to contractual write-offs, net production falls even with the same number of visits, and every cost percentage rises with it.

Does cash basis accounting make overhead look higher?

It can. On cash basis the denominator is deposits, so a slow month for insurance payments raises overhead with no change in the schedule. Read overhead against net production.

Share this post