How To · 7 min read
Benchmarking overhead is not comparing one number to 55% to 65%. It is four steps: fix the denominator, know what the benchmark sources can and cannot tell you, put every cost on the right line, and compare only the lines that have a real benchmark. When a line is off, read the trend and size the gap before you act on it.
Most owners benchmark overhead by dividing total expenses by whatever revenue number is handy and comparing the result to a figure they heard at a study club. That produces a number, but not an answer. A total that passes can hide a line that is badly off, a total that fails can be a production problem rather than a spending one, and two of the lines owners worry about most have no legitimate benchmark at all. Here is the method we use, line by line, with a worked example.
Every dental overhead benchmark in this post is a share of net production: the value of the dentistry you did, after contractual insurance write-offs. Not gross production, which still includes fees you were never going to collect. Not collections, which swing with insurance timing. A practice that collects 98% to 100% of net production will get nearly the same answer either way, which is why collections can look like a safe substitute. It stops being safe the month a large carrier pays late.
Two more conditions. Use closed books, meaning every account reconciled and the month final. And use accrual, or at least a cash-to-accrual view, because on cash basis a quarterly premium or a big supply order lands in one month and makes overhead swing for reasons that have nothing to do with cost.
One month is noise. Read each month against last month and the same month last year, and judge it against the ranges on a trailing 12 months, so a single odd month does not send you chasing it.
The line-item ranges come from the practice benchmarking report produced jointly by the Academy of Dental CPAs and the National Society of Certified Healthcare Business Consultants. The edition we work from carries 2024 data, and its publisher warns that some specialties have very small samples, so treat the ranges as guardrails, not verdicts.
The other major source is the ADA's Survey of Dental Practice, which is free, national and weighted. It reports total practice expenses, but it does not split them into staff, supplies, lab or rent. It reports expenses as amounts per dentist, and its one published expense ratio is measured against collections with shareholder salaries included, not against net production. So the ADA is the right place to see what an average owner dentist's practice spends per dentist in total, and the wrong place to pull a line-item target from. Our total overhead post shows how the same practice can produce overhead figures almost 40 points apart depending on which base and which definition you use.
A benchmark compares your line to a line built the same way. If yours is built differently, the comparison is wrong before you read it.
| Line | What belongs in it | Common miscoding |
|---|---|---|
| Staff payroll | Wages, employer payroll taxes and benefits for every team member except owners and associates | Associate pay or owner W-2 mixed in |
| Clinical supplies | Consumables used in treatment | Lab fees, aligners, office supplies |
| Outside lab | Fees paid to dental labs | Aligner cases booked as supplies |
| Owner compensation | The owner's W-2, draws and benefits | Spread across payroll and admin |
| Associate cost | Associate pay and its taxes and benefits | Booked inside staff payroll |
The aligner line is worth a second look. Clear aligner cases coded to supplies push supplies over its range and make lab look healthy when neither reading is true. Our post on coding Invisalign as a supply instead of lab shows how far that one coding choice moves both numbers.
These are the ranges we use, all as a share of net production:
| Line | Healthy range | One point on $1,000,000 of net production |
|---|---|---|
| Staff payroll | 25% to 30% | $10,000 |
| Hygiene labor (part of staff payroll) | 8% to 10% | $10,000 |
| Clinical supplies | 5% to 7% | $10,000 |
| Outside lab | 5% to 7% | $10,000 |
| Clinical cost (supplies plus lab) | 10% to 14% | $10,000 |
| Total overhead, owner pay excluded | 55% to 65% | $10,000 |
A few notes on reading them. Staff payroll is the line that decides most outcomes, because it is four to five times the size of supplies or lab on their own. A staffing percentage that drifts up is often a production signal before it is a payroll one, which our staffing percentage post explains. Supplies and lab are read together as clinical cost, because a practice that does more of its own work in house shifts cost from lab to supplies, so the split moves even when the total does not. And total overhead excludes the owner's own pay, which is the single most common reason a self-computed overhead figure lands near 90%.
Our free Dental Practice Benchmark Scorecard lets you check these lines against the healthy ranges in about two minutes.
This is the part most benchmarking advice gets wrong. Some costs scale with the dentistry itself, so a share of production means the same thing from one practice to the next. Those get a range. Other costs are set by something else entirely, and a national range for them would be noise even if someone published one.
| Line | What actually sets it | How to read it instead |
|---|---|---|
| Occupancy (rent, utilities, repairs) | Your building and your local real estate market | The amount and its trend against your own lease history |
| Marketing | How mature your practice is and how crowded your market is | Cost per new patient from your own books |
| Owner compensation | Your entity and your pay election | Track it, separate from profit |
| Owner discretionary | Your choices | Track it, no right level |
| Associate cost | The contract you signed, and its base | Against that associate's own production |
Rent is the one owners most want a number for, so here is what exists. The only measured national data is the IRS Statistics of Income series for dental sole proprietorships, which puts rent at about 4% of business receipts. That covers only sole proprietors and measures against receipts, not net production, so it is context, not a target. Our occupancy post walks through why the same lease reads as 4.1% in one practice and 6.9% in another. Marketing follows the same logic, covered in our post on marketing spend.
If an advisor, a dashboard or a benchmark article hands you a percentage range for rent or marketing, ask where it came from. We have looked, and there is no credible source.
Here is an illustrative practice with $1,000,000 of net production over the trailing 12 months, owner pay excluded and no associate.
| Line | Annual cost | Share of net production | Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staff payroll | $290,000 | 29.0% | Inside 25% to 30%, near the top |
| Clinical supplies | $62,000 | 6.2% | Inside 5% to 7% |
| Outside lab | $78,000 | 7.8% | Above 5% to 7% |
| Clinical cost combined | $140,000 | 14.0% | At the top of 10% to 14% |
| Occupancy | $70,000 | 7.0% | No range. Compare to your own lease |
| Marketing | $25,000 | 2.5% | No range. Compare to new patients won |
| Insurance, software, admin and fees | $60,000 | 6.0% | Part of the remainder |
| Depreciation and interest | $45,000 | 4.5% | Part of the remainder |
| Total overhead | $630,000 | 63.0% | Inside 55% to 65% |
The total passes, and that is exactly when owners stop reading. Two lines deserve a question. Lab is 0.8 points over its range, about $8,000 a year. Before treating that as a price problem, check the mix: a year with more implant crowns or aligner cases raises lab for reasons that also raise production, and a coding error makes the number meaningless. Staff payroll at 29% is inside its range but near the top, and on a trailing view you would want to know whether it rose because payroll grew or because production slipped.
Work in this order, and the order matters.
Check the denominator first. Pull the 12-month trend of net production. If it fell, every percentage rose at once without any new spending, which is the pattern behind rising overhead with low volume. That is a schedule question, not a cost one.
Check the coding second. A line that jumped in one month and stayed there is often a coding change, a new vendor mapped to the wrong account, or a cost that moved between lab and supplies.
Then size the gap. One point is $10,000 on $1,000,000 of production, on every line. A two-point miss on staff payroll is $20,000 a year, more than most small categories cost in total, and owners reliably spend their attention in the opposite order, because the small lines are the ones that feel wasteful.
Only then decide. A benchmark tells you which question to ask. It does not tell you the answer, and a practice at 67% with rising production can be in better shape than one at 58% that got there by running short staffed.
P.S. Reciprocity Accounting closes your books by the 10th with every expense on the right line and every ratio measured on net production, so the benchmarks you read compare like with like. See how we can help your practice.
As a share of net production: staff payroll 25% to 30%, clinical supplies 5% to 7%, outside lab 5% to 7%, supplies and lab combined 10% to 14%, and total overhead 55% to 65% with the owner's own pay excluded. The ranges come from the ADCPA and NSCHBC benchmarking report.
There is no credible production-based benchmark for rent. Occupancy cost is set by your building and your local market, not by the dentistry. The only measured national data, IRS figures for dental sole proprietorships, puts rent at about 4% of business receipts, which is context rather than a target.
Net production. The standard dental ranges are built on it, and collections swing with insurance timing. If you collect 98% to 100% of net production the answers will be close, but the benchmark is defined on production.
The two most common reasons are owner pay included in expenses and a falling denominator. Take owner compensation out, recompute on net production from closed books, and look at the 12-month production trend before you look at a single expense line.
Monthly, from closed books: this month against last month and the same month last year, with the ranges judged on a trailing 12 months. One month is too noisy to act on by itself.